Parable of the Pharisee and Tax-Collector - Pride and Humility

Homily for the Thirtieth Sunday of Year C

by Fr. Tommy Lane

There is a journey we all have to make, a pilgrimage we are all called to undertake, and that is the journey from pride to humility. That is the journey or pilgrimage that the Pharisee in today’s Gospel (Luke 18:9-14) needs to make. His statement in today’s Gospel shows that he is in need of such a spiritual journey. Currently his point of departure is, “I thank you God that I am not grasping, unjust, adulterous like the rest of mankind, and especially that I am not like this tax-collector here” (Luke 18:11) but his destination needs to be that of the tax-collector, “God be merciful to me a sinner.” (Luke 18:13) It was easy for the Pharisee to fall into the temptation of thinking he was better because he really was a good man. He fasted twice a week whereas Jewish law asked to fast only once a year. He paid tithes, giving away 10% of all his income, whereas Jewish law required one to tithe 10% of grain and firstborn of the flock. He was a really good man but he lacked compassion for others because he had not experienced problems himself. He did not have a cross to carry and so he did not have sensitivity to others who were suffering. Nothing helps to mature us like suffering does. He had never fallen in life so he was proud. Pride comes before a fall. And often a fall is what it takes for someone to lose their pride and realize that they are human the same as everybody else. When it comes to sin and grace we are all on the same playing field, none of us deserves or earns heaven, it is a gift from God to us won by Jesus’ suffering, death and resurrection. This is shown by a funeral custom of the former Austrian royal family.

In Vienna in Austria there is a church in which the former ruling family in Austria, the Hapsburgs, are buried. When royal funerals used to arrive the mourners knocked at the door of the church to be allowed in. A priest inside would ask ‘Who is it that desires admission here?’ A guard would call out, ‘His apostolic majesty, the emperor’. The priest would answer, ‘I don’t know him’. They would knock a second time, and again the priest would ask who was there. The funeral guard outside would announce, ‘The highest emperor’. A second time the priest would say, ‘I don’t know him’. A third time they would knock on the door and the priest would ask ‘Who is it?’ The third time the answer would be, ‘A poor sinner, your brother.’
(An edited form of the story in A World of Stories for Preachers and Teachers: And All Who Love Stories That Move and Challenge (page 326-327) by William J. Bausch and published by Twenty-Third Publications, PO Box 180, Mystic, CT 06355, USA, © 1988, and used here with permission.)

The progression in the questions and answers of the former Austrian royal family show a progression to humility, a progression to the stance of the tax-collector in Jesus’ parable today. There is some of the pride of the Pharisee and some of the humility of the tax-collector in each of us. Each of us, to a greater or lesser degree, is called by Jesus in today’s Gospel to make that journey from pride to humility. In a sense, the Pharisee thought he was God but there is only room in any person’s life for one God, so if you’re God, God in heaven loses out. That’s why in the parable the humble tax collector who asked God for mercy went home at rights with God and the proud Pharisee did not. If we are not sensitive to other people we are not very sensitive to God either. The Pharisee was not sensitive to the tax-collector and was not sensitive to God. The tax-collector was sensitive to his own failings and weakness and was also sensitive to God. Sensitivity to other people and sensitivity to God nearly always to hand in hand.

“The proud cannot bring themselves to hold out empty hands to God, they insist on offering virtues, good works, self denials, anything in order not to have nothing. They want to be beautiful for him from their own resources, whereas we are beautiful only because God looks on us and makes us beautiful. God cannot give himself to us unless our hands are empty to receive him. The deepest reason why so few of us are saints is because we will not let God love us.”
(from Guidelines for Mystical Prayer pages 83-84 by Ruth Burrows, published and copyright 1976 by Sheed and Ward, longer excerpt)

The royal Hapsburg family in Austria were allowed into the church for burial when they admitted that their deceased was a poor sinner. We are all called to make the journey from saying like the Pharisee, “I thank you God that I am not grasping, unjust, adulterous like the rest of mankind, and especially that I am not like this tax-collector here” (Luke 18:11) to arrive at the point where we can say like the tax-collector, “God be merciful to me a sinner.” (Luke 18:13) If we experience suffering or a cross in life it is easier for us to make that journey from pride to humility. “God be merciful to me a sinner.”

Copyright © Fr. Tommy Lane 2013

This homily was delivered when I was engaged in parish ministry in Ireland before joining the faculty of Mount St. Mary’s Seminary, Emmitsburg, Maryland.

More Homilies for the Thirtieth Sunday Year C

Only by admitting our sin to God like the tax collector can we receive God’s Peace 2010

Related Homilies: pride/humility We are all Equal in Dignity before God

Be Gentle in Carrying Out Your Business

The greatest among you must be your servant